Michael's Space

Technology changes the world, serves the people.
  C++博客 :: 首页 :: 新随笔 :: 联系 :: 聚合  :: 管理

Woman steals thousands from ATM

Glitch let cash flow freely after Katrina
Thursday, December 07, 2006
By Matt Scallan

(本文转载自:http://www.nola.com/search/index.ssf?/base/news-3/1165474781197240.xml?NERP&coll=1)

[Michael]: 前不久在本人身边就发生过类似情况,国内客户在一ATM(自动柜员机)上取款时发现ATM软件的漏洞(取100元帐户只被扣1元),于是拼命取款上十万最终辞去工作,逃离人们视线.
 殊不知本文中该美国居民因类似事件被FBI追查并被送上法庭,最终以盗窃罪将被判处至多10年的徒刑,并追加一定的罚款.


A Destrehan woman with $600 in her credit union account took advantage of a software glitch to steal more than $14,000 with her ATM card in the weeks after Hurricane Katrina, U.S. Attorney Jim Letten said Wednesday.

Shelita Grandpre, 32, pleaded guilty to bank larceny charges in U.S. Eastern District Court last week after admitting that she knowingly spent the money after discovering a software glitch in the ASI Federal Credit Union's ATM software that allowed customers to withdraw unlimited amounts of cash and make unlimited purchases with their debit cards.

Five other ASI members have pleaded guilty to similar charges. The Elmwood-based credit union has 14 branches in Orleans, Jefferson, St. Tammany, St. Charles, Lafourche and Evangeline parishes.

Audrey Cerise, ASI's chief executive officer, said credit union officers discovered the glitch three days after the storm after the institution transferred its operations to another company when the power failed at its Jefferson Parish headquarters.

"We had a choice. We could have cut off ATM services for all of our members, or we could take the chance on losing some money," she said.

Many of the credit union's members who evacuated from the storm took advantage of the glitch and withdrew more than they had in their accounts. But the vast majority repaid the money after the storm, Cerise said.

"Our faith was not misplaced," Cerise said.

Cerise said many who withdrew more than they had thanked her employees for letting them make overdrafts in the weeks after the storm.

"I don't know that I wouldn't have done the same thing in their shoes," she said. "They didn't have money for food. They didn't have money for gas."

Cerise said the credit union has moved to avoid repeating the problem by mirroring its computerized transactions at its Ville Platte branch, rather than using an outside vendor.

According to Grandpre's guilty plea, she made withdrawals and purchases totaling $14,056.21 in the Monroe, Baton Rouge and New Orleans areas between Aug. 30, 2005, and Sept. 17, 2005. She admitted to FBI agents that she knowingly overdrafted her account, Letten said.

Grandpre pleaded guilty to bank larceny and could be sentenced to up to 10 years in prison and a $250,000 fine. Sentencing is scheduled for March 6 before U.S. District Judge Jay Zainey.

Others who have pleaded guilty on similar charges, along with the amount they are accused of overdrafting, are Renesha Brown of New Orleans, $8,483; Chassity Deshone Hulbert Irving of New Orleans, $18,334; Michelle Taylor of New Orleans, $7,488; Charlotte J. Whitley of Gretna, $8,024; and her daughter, Graylyn Whitley of New Orleans, $7,943. The defendants are set to be sentenced early next year.

More cases are pending, Letten said.

. . . . . . .

Matt Scallan may be reached at mscallan@timespicayune.com or (985) 652-0953.

Feedback

# 男子趁ATM机出错提款171次后潜逃被判无期  回复  更多评论   

2007-12-18 13:53 by 奔跑的阿甘
男子趁ATM机出错提款171次后潜逃被判无期http://www.sina.com.cn 2007年12月17日01:31 人民网 (来源:新快报)

  本报讯 (记者 黄琼 见习记者 李斯璐) ATM机出故障,取1000元卡里才扣1元!一见有此好事,小许觉得发财的机会来了,立即找来朋友小郭“共富贵”。随后,小郭和小许分别从中提取了1.8万元和17.5万元后各自潜逃。事发后,小郭主动自首后被判处有期徒刑一年,而潜逃一年被抓获的小许日前被广州市中院以盗窃罪判处无期徒刑。同为盗取,为何法院判决如此悬殊?小许认为法院量刑过重,已向省高院提出上诉。

  账户里170元取走17.5万

  据公诉机关指控,2006年4月21日晚10时,被告人许霆来到天河区黄埔大道某银行的ATM取款机取款。结果取出1000元后,他惊讶地发现银行卡账户里只被扣了1元,狂喜之下,许霆连续取款5.4万元。当晚,许霆回到住处,将此事告诉了同伴郭安山。两人随即再次前往提款,之后反复操作多次。后经警方查实,许霆先后取款171笔,合计17.5万元;郭安山则取款1.8万元。事后,二人各携赃款潜逃。

  同年11月7日,郭安山向公安机关投案自首,并全额退还赃款1.8万元。经天河区法院审理后,法院认定其构成盗窃罪,但考虑到其自首并主动退赃,故对其判处有期徒刑一年,并处罚金1000元。而潜逃一年的许霆,17.5万元赃款因投资失败而挥霍一空,今年5月在陕西宝鸡火车站被警方抓获。日前,广州市中院审理后认为,被告许霆以非法侵占为目的,伙同同案人采用秘密手段,盗窃金融机构,数额特别巨大,行为已构成盗窃罪,遂判处无期徒刑,剥夺政治权利终身,并处没收个人全部财产。

  对此,许霆的辩护律师表示异议,他表示ATM机出错就是银行的错,另外,银行有足够时间追回款项,只是因为周末而错过,因此可以将这17.5万元视之为“遗忘物”,许霆的离开行为仅构成侵占罪。

  171次恶意提款获重判

  同为利用ATM机漏洞盗取,为何两人判刑如此悬殊呢?广州市律师协会刑事委员会主任钟闻东表示,在该案中虽然看似法院量刑过重,但其实仍在法定范围内。钟闻东表示,许霆以非法侵占为目的,采取秘密手段盗窃,明知其银行卡内只有170多元,但在发现银行系统出错时即产生恶意占有的故意,并分171次恶意取款17.5万元而非法占有,得手后潜逃并将赃款挥霍花光,其行为符合盗窃罪的法定构成要件。同时,虽然郭安山是与他一同盗窃,但二人并不存在共同犯罪故意,只是采取相同犯罪手法各自实施,最后得款也是根据各自卡内各自提取所得,因此二人并不构成共同犯罪,仅以各自取款数来计算盗窃金额。而根据刑法关于盗窃罪的相关规定,同案人郭安山个人盗窃金额数额不大且全部退赃,同时主动自首并向公安机关交代与许犯案经过等,因此获得从轻处理并无不妥。

  柜员机视为金融机构太严苛?

  根据刑法关于盗窃罪的解释,个人盗窃公私财物价值三万元至十万元以上的,为“数额特别巨大”,而我国刑法对此相应的规定是,处十年以上有期徒刑或者无期徒刑,并处罚金或没收财产。而在本案中,许霆不仅将巨款挥霍一空,还私自潜逃直至被抓获,并无任何可获从轻或减轻的量刑情节。因此,法院适用了规定的最高刑并无不妥,仍在法定范围内。

  那么,盗取ATM机是否构成盗窃金融机构呢?不少市民认为把ATM机视为金融机构太过严苛,“那岂不是满大街都是金融机构了!”对此,钟闻东认为,从财产所有方面来讲,ATM机也应视为金融机构。因为ATM机内的现金也是来源于金融机构,其财产的所有权属于金融机构,其可以看做金融机构财产的延伸。同时ATM机为金融机构所有和管理,当然是金融机构不可分割的一部分。来源:新快报

# re: 美国居民利用ATM的软件漏洞透支取款被判入狱10年  回复  更多评论   

2007-12-20 10:56 by 奔跑的阿甘
Cash-happy ATM lands man life in prison
http://uk.reuters.com/article/oddlyEnoughNews/idUKPEK87220071218

Tue Dec 18, 2007 8:24am GMT

BEIJING (Reuters) - A man in China's southern city of Guangzhou has been jailed for life for taking funds from a malfunctioning ATM, local media reported on Tuesday.

In April last year, Xu Ting let his friend in on his secret that the ATM deducted only 1 yuan from his account for every 1,000 yuan withdrawn.

"Xu subsequently withdrew 175,000 yuan (12,000 pounds) in 171 transactions while Guo withdrew 18,000 yuan," the Beijing News reported.

Guo was jailed for a year after turning himself in while Xu remained on the run for a year before being apprehended and sentenced to life for theft.

The sentence has sparked an outcry from local media.

"Sentenced to life for unexpectedly discovering an ATM's malfunction and enticed into committing a crime is too harsh," the Beijing News said in an editorial.

Xu's lawyer said the ATM was the responsibility of the bank and it had had ample time to recover the lost funds. Xu's actions should come under the lesser charge of embezzlement, it added.

Xu has appealed against his sentence.

(Reporting by Beijing Newsroom; Editing by Nick Macfie)

只有注册用户登录后才能发表评论。
网站导航: 博客园   IT新闻   BlogJava   知识库   博问   管理